My Credit Card Story Part 2

Posted by Fitz Villafuerte under Guest Posts, Personal Finance on September 4, 2014

I’m currently on vacation so I’m letting one of my friends, Carlos, share his story today.

Last year, he wrote an article about credit cards, which you can read here: My Credit Card Story (Part 1).

In that post, he shared how he got his first credit card, and his realization that credit cards are not evil and if used correctly, it can give you financial leverage.

What does that mean – financial leverage? He explains that now below…

credit-card-1

My credit card is the best investment I made this year.

I’m sure to you, that sounds either really stupid or really pathetic. Normally, I would think so too. But since this isn’t the end of my article, obviously I have an angle.

I do, but that’s going to take a bit more explaining, and I’ll need to correct a couple of incorrect advice.

The last time I wrote I guest post here, I audaciously said that my credit card could help me save money.

This is correction #1: Credit cards are not bad; and they can possibly save you money.

Most people look at credit card points and the rewards as a form of savings, if used right. It is – but that’s very small, so I’ve never really bothered myself chasing reward points.

But scouring the different types of cards I saw two that offered rebates. One gave 2% rebate at any grocery (and in some department stores too); and the other one, promised a 5% rebate – but only for a specific store.

As it happened, I was already shopping at that store. It was accessible and the prices are comparable to SM, sometimes even a little cheaper.

So I took that card.

And now you’re saying, “That’s it?! 5% rebate savings is your best investment?!” and you’re again thinking that it’s either really stupid or really pathetic.

But no, that’s not it. And the way I see it, the return on my investment for the year is almost-assuredly higher than your equity fund for the same year. But let’s get back to my story.

When I applied for that new credit card, I surprisingly got denied – twice!

I had a decent salary and good credit card history (I pay as I purchase! They don’t even have to wait an extra day to get my money). I had savings and investments. And yet they denied me and refused to say why.

I was bitter and frustrated, but I decided to keep trying.

I searched online and learned that if I open a time deposit account with their bank and get a manager’s endorsement then I will instantly be approved. (Apparently regardless of credit history, which doesn’t seem like a sound business practice. But I digress.)

So I forked over Php15,000 into a TD account and got my card. The interest for one year was an astounding 0.875%!

And yes, that’s really lame. Astoundingly lame.

credit-card-2

So how can my 5% savings plus P106.46 be better than your equity fund?

This is where I make correction #2: Don’t use your card sparingly; and certainly not only for emergencies. Use it every time possible, but only if you have the cash to pay it off immediately, of course.

Advertisement


Our grocery budget for a month is P11,000. Unfortunately, only a portion of that gets spent on that specific, rebate-possible store. But my wife was unimpressed with that 5% and is too busy to purposefully visit that store every time. That just wouldn’t work out well.

So I instead took the time to be the main grocery shopper. My wife was happy, I get my rebate and all it took was bit more legwork. I think of it as doing some power-walking and weight-lifting during lunchtime.

And so I made sure that if anything we need is in that store, it will be bought in that store. That’s not always possible though, so only around P9,400 is consistently spent there.

Now this is where thinking differently helps a lot.

I did not save money.

That’s stupid; I was getting rebates right? Sure, but that’s after you spend.

But I did not lessen the grocery budget. Also I did not buy more stuff. In effect I was acting “normally” and accumulating the rebates like they were points.

So for one year, that P15,000 time deposit will return not just P106.46 cash but also P5,640 almost-cash in the form of rebates. That’s a 38.3% return on my principal. You think your equity fund can beat that this year?

You’re probably arguing that I’m just playing with words and figures, or I’m just being too smart for my own good.

We can treat this as correction #3: Ending up with more money is the key concept. Terminology is necessary for understanding; not earning.

But really, it’s no different than parking my 15k in a stock or UITF for one year. In both cases I have the exact same principal (P15,000), spend the rest of my money exactly the same (grocery budget) and live the exactly the same way – aside from some lunch break workouts, but it’s close enough.

But I found a way to chase greater returns without taking risk. In loftier circumstances, that might be described as exploiting a market inefficiency.

credit-card-3

My experience isn’t something that’s widely repeatable, but I believe there’s good value in sharing to you this story.

What we have now, especially the options available to us, are not set in stone. It pays to keep looking and keep thinking. And when we find something that looks worthwhile, we can expect adversity – sometimes a lot heck of it.

It’s generally said (and sometimes accepted) that credit cards are bad and will get you in debt. Using them responsibly usually carries the connotation of using them sparingly. And that higher returns carries high risk; meaning if you want to get better returns, you’re forced to take more risks.

Had I followed those common and well-meaning – but generic – advice, I would not have gotten this “better” deal. 

That’s why it’s important to understand how things work (especially money), decide for ourselves, and generally – just think.

It pays (to borrow a tagline) to think different.

This guest post is contributed by Carlos, an IT professional and amateur investor dreaming of being an entrepreneur. You can visit his blog entitled, The Personal Finance Apprentice.

Important note:

Carlos is a financially savvy person, and that’s why he is able to leverage his credit card spending to his advantage.

If you don’t have the habit of saving, still struggling with debt, or cannot even maintain a spending budget, then I strongly advise that you focus on improving your financial habits first.

———
Photo credits: ep_technology, consumerist and moneyblognewz


SELECT AN ARTICLE TO READ NEXT BELOW:


Tags: , , ,

11 Responses to “My Credit Card Story Part 2”


  1. Tintin says:

    May I ask which bank offers a TD account and a credit card at the same time?

  2. Jillsabs says:

    Oooh! What card is this? A 5% rebate is very sweet.

  3. Theresa Aguilar says:

    if I may add, for frequent traveller or a jet setter getting a miles card is really rewarding. imagine getting 1 mile for every P33 – 40 (depends on the bank) spent, that’s a lot of mabuhay miles at the end of the year. we’re able to get HK tickets every Christmas for free (airline base fare)

  4. JMG says:

    enrol all your utility bills in your credit card.
    i bought a ref this year, partially paid using my accumulated points in pesos terms equaled to P21k.

  5. Rose says:

    Wow! what a great idea to get a credit card again! I have cut all my credit cards thinking they are just a way to spend. I think I have an idea what the credit card is 🙂 I have been thinking of getting one for some time. Now is the time!

  6. edelweiza says:

    I believe you. I got rebates myself from my credit card last year. For every 10k worth of purchases, P250 could be earned as rebates. I was able to earn P500 because of my 20k plus worth of purchases (which were actually not mine but my sibling’s who asked me to use my card in exchange for their cash, sayang daw ang points ko!). As long as we know how to use our credit cards wisely and to our advantage, credit cards are a good and harmless financial tool. 🙂

  7. MD says:

    Quite accurate as I earn about 10-12k rebates a year with one card. That’s like investing P1M in the usual time deposit for a year WITHOUT ANY PRINCIPAL. I just used the card for my usual purchases.

  8. Glad to see posts like this every time! Aside from credit card rebates from groceries, this is also the same principle why I think people should use STORED VALUE CARD at the MRT. For P100, its like you get up to 14% rebate because of the free ride you get when you use the last remaining credit in your MRT card! And you can’t get as much as 14% return on a weekly basis that easily anywhere!

    I am always left with only 1 peso remaining in my stored value card, and very excited to use it for a P12 ride or a P15 ride! Even if sometimes, I only get a 5 peso discount, in my mind, that is still an easy 5% rebate. Not to mention the convenience of not lining up anymore when you use a stored value card. This is my only consolation when I use the MRT with all the problems they’re encountering for a long time now. 🙂

    The same also when I buy a P300 load that gives me 30 free texts! That’s an easy 10% rebate! I am grateful everyday that rebates and opportunity to save are everywhere. Thank you for sharing! 🙂

  9. Cathy says:

    A sensible story. Please share what credit cards offer rebates. thanks

  10. Edmar says:

    what bank and grocery store they give rebate?

  11. Oscar says:

    Hi Coach Fitz…

    Nice piece…

    There is really some nice things about this article…. I thought I was one of the few people looking at how great credit rebates are..

Leave a Comment and Join the Discussion